Nintendo is often regarded as a master of vertical integration. From console manufacturing to game creation, Nintendo manages the whole process internally. Firms with this level of creative oversight are few and far between, placing Nintendo in a category with powerhouses like Disney.
Still, a single franchise exists as a significant exception. According to numerous reports, Pokémon is Nintendo's most lucrative intellectual property. Some figures, albeit hard to confirm, claim it is the top-earning media franchise of all time. This wealth comes from omnipresent merchandise, game sales, and a booming trading card enterprise. But curiously, Pokémon is not entirely Nintendo's creation.
The mainline Pokémon video games are released exclusively on Nintendo consoles, but they are made by the external studio Game Freak. Together with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the company behind the trading card game), Nintendo is a part-owner of The Pokémon Company. This entity manages the worldwide merchandising empire that brings in billions. Even, the enormous hit Pokémon Go was created and published by third-party studios under a license from The Pokémon Company, functioning at a considerable distance from Nintendo's immediate supervision.
A Precedent of External Success
This setup might seem unthinkable for a company renowned for its desire for control. Yet, Pokémon was not the first instance an external game drove Nintendo's success.
In 1989, Nintendo released the groundbreaking Game Boy. However, its in-house designers had not yet discovered the perfect game for it. That solution came in the form of the external title Tetris. Nintendo's fierce pursuit to secure the rights for the Game Boy port of Tetris is legendary in the video game world. The triumph of Tetris cemented the Game Boy's position and paved the path for Nintendo's long-term leadership in handheld devices. This portable business offered crucial stability during difficult times for its home console operations and ultimately culminated in the hybrid Switch.
Despite masterful ports of its flagship series, a truly groundbreaking handheld game was not conceived in-house. Rather, that spark originated with former writer Satoshi Tajiri, creator of Game Freak. Upon discovering that Game Boys could be linked via a cable, he envisioned exchanging virtual creatures, drawing from his youthful memories of collecting bugs.
Game Freak pitched the idea to Nintendo, which quickly seized upon it. Yet, it took years for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the expansive RPG released in 1996. A couple of years went by before the games, alongside a trading card game and an animated series, burst into a worldwide craze. Pokémon prolonged the lifespan of the Game Boy deep into its 14-year run and essentially guaranteed Nintendo's economic security.
Why Not Buy Everything?
It may appear strange that Nintendo did not move to completely acquire Game Freak and Pokémon once its colossal potential became clear. This is exactly the sort of move a corporation like Disney would have taken. Rather, the tripartite alliance between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was established as early as 1998. This developed into The Pokémon Company, which today manages the global franchise.
Nintendo has a history of tight-knit, enduring relationships with select independent studios, such as HAL Laboratory and Intelligent Systems, without buying them. But, Pokémon's success was of a different magnitude. Why then not grab the whole pie? It is possible that creators Satoshi Tajiri and Tsunekazu Ishihara were not prepared to sell their brainchild. It is also conceivable that Nintendo's executives, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the astute Satoru Iwata, made a deliberate choice not to pursue full acquisition.
The Benefits of Separation
In hindsight, this setup may have been exceptionally wise. Would Nintendo have authorized the vast range of branded products or dived into the card business with such abandon? The Pokémon Company, functioning with a measure of autonomy, could execute a voracious strategy to claim global mindshare and revenue.
This distance enabled Nintendo to enjoy the financial rewards while remaining relatively insulated from the periodic backlashes related to the franchise. When concerns emerged about the trading card game impact, the scrutiny was directed elsewhere from Nintendo. Also, the occasionally variable quality of modern Game Freak titles is a public relations price largely borne by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo itself.
A Enduring Symbiosis
In many ways, this arrangement reflects a core Nintendo philosophy. The company is renowned for not tampering with what works.|Nintendo generally avoids unnecessary